November 2006

A.M. No. 06-4-219-RTC.  November 2, 2006

Re: report on the judicial audit and physical inventory.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 144062.  November 2, 2006

The Bases Conversion and Development Authority, et al. Vs. Elpidio Uy.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. Nos. 148839-40.  November 2, 2006

Nagkahiusang Mamumuo Sa Picop Resources, Inc. – Southern Philippines Federation of Labor (NAMAPRI – SPFL), Artemio Q. Avila, et al. Vs. Court of Appeals, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 154006.  November 2, 2006

Star Paper Corporation Vs. Carlito Espiritu, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 157906.  November 2, 2006

Joaquinita P. Capili Vs. Sps. Dominador Cardaña and Rosalita Cardaña.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 160618.  November 2, 2006

Dennis D. Sy Vs. Metropolitan Bank & Trust Company.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 165724.  November 2, 2006

Zamora Realty and Development Corporation Vs. Office of the President of the Philippines, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166403.  November 2, 2006

Benzon O. Aldemita Vs. Heirs of Melquiades Silva.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169891.  November 2, 2006

Philippine National Railways Vs. Ethel Brunty and Juan Manuel M. Garcia.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 162366.  November 10, 2006

Federica M. Serrano, et al. Vs. Sps. Anselmo Gutierrez.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 163763.  November 10, 2006

Malayan Realty, Inc. Vs. Uy Han Yong.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 165879.  November 10, 2006

Maria B. Ching Vs. Joseph C. Goyanko, Jr., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-05-2092.  November 10, 2006

Atty. Perfecto A.S. Laguio, Jr. Vs. Mila Amante-Casicas.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. 2004-15-SC.  November 16, 2006

Prosecutor Agapito B. Rosales Vs. Engr. Celerino Buenaventura.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.C. No. 6266.  November 16, 2006

Estela Anastacio-Briones Vs. Atty. Alfredo A. Zapanta.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.C. No. 7280.  November 16, 2006

Dahlia S. Gacias Vs. Atty. Alexander Bulauitan.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 149748.  November 16, 2006

Jang Lim, et al. Vs. Court of Appeals, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. Nos. 157236-45.  November 16, 2006

Romeo D. Lonzanida Vs. Sandiganbayan.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 159373.  November 16, 2006

Jose R. Moreno, Jr. Vs. Private Management Office.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 159991.  November 16, 2006

Carmelino F. Pansacola Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 161136.  November 16, 2006

Vagilidad Vs. Vagilidad.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 164858.  November 16, 2006

Henry P. Lanot Vs. Commission on Elections.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

Separate Opinion

CJ. Panganiban

J. Tinga

G.R. No. 166501.  November 16, 2006

Ernesto B. Francisco, Jr. Vs. Hon. Bayani F. Fernando.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 172274.  November 16, 2006

Romeo D. Cabarlo Vs. People of the Philippines.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. MTJ-03-1503.  November 16, 2006

National Bureau of Investigation Vs. Judge Luisito T. Adaoag.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-03-1737.  November 16, 2006

Nicolas Paclibar Vs. Renan V. Pamposa.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.C. No. 7123.  November 20, 2006

Maria Divina Cruz-Villanueva Vs. Atty. Carlos P. Rivera, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 155574.  November 20, 2006

Timoteo A. Garcia Vs. Sandiganbayan.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 156888.  November 20, 2006

Pedro R. Santiago Vs. Subic Bay Metropolitan Authority.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 157117.  November 20, 2006

Coastal Subic Bay Terminal, Inc. Vs. Department of Labor and Employment, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 162331.  November 20, 2006

Lepanto Consolidated Mining Co. Vs. Wmc Resources Int’l. Pty. Ltd., Wmc Philippines, Inc., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 164545.  November 20, 2006

Lorbe Rebucan y Baltazar Vs. People of the Philippines.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. Nos. 166143-47 / G.R. No. 166891.  November 20, 2006

Abdusakur M. Tan, et al. Vs. Commission on Elections, et al. / Benjamin T. Loong Vs. Commission on Elections, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. Nos. 169295-96.  November 20, 2006

Remington Industrial Sales Corporation Vs. Erlinda Castaneda.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170220.  November 20, 2006

Josefina S. Lubrica Vs. Land Bank of the Philippines.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170522.  November 20, 2006

Celso Lopez Ocate Vs. Commission on Elections.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170829.  November 20, 2006

Perla G. Patricio Vs. Marcelino G. Dario III, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 173290.  November 20, 2006

Zenaida M. Limbona Vs. Judge Ralph S. Lee, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. 2005-26-SC.  November 22, 2006

Re: lost checks issued to the late Roderick Roy P. Melliza, etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.C. No. 7252.  November 22, 2006

Johnny Ng Vs. Atty. Benjamin C. Alar.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 142351.  November 22, 2006

St. Martin Funeral Homes Vs. National Labor Relations Commission.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 148490.  November 22, 2006

7k Corporation Vs. National Labor Relations Commission, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 149764.  November 22, 2006

Philippine Overseas Telecommunications Corporation Vs. Enrique Gutierrez, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 152984.  November 22, 2006

William G. Kwong Vs. Atty. Ramon Gargantos, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 162308.  November 22, 2006

G & M Philippines, Inc. Vs. Romil V. Cuambot.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167743.  November 22, 2006

Hilario P. Soriano Vs. Ombudsman Simeon V. Marcelo, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167844.  November 22, 2006

Office of the Ombudsman Vs. Court of Appeals, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169341.  November 22, 2006

City of Cebu Vs. Vicente B. Del Rosario.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 127636.  November 24, 2006

E. Rommel Realty and Development Corporation, et al. Vs. Sta. Lucia Realty Development Corporation.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 132834.  November 24, 2006

Ruperto Lucero, Jr., et al. Vs. City Government of Pasig.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 155645.  November 24, 2006

Philippine Long Distance Telephone Company, Inc. (PLDT) Vs. Mayflor T. Ylagan.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 156903.  November 24, 2006

Spouses Carlos and Teresita Rustia Vs. Emerita Rivera.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 157107.  November 24, 2006

Alpine Lending Investors Vs. Estrella Corpuz.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 158960.  November 24, 2006

Lorna Frances Filipino Vs. F. Walter R. Macabuhay.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 160805.  November 24, 2006

Spouses Adiel De La Cena, et al. Vs. Spouses Jose Briones, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 161086.  November 24, 2006

Civil Service Commission Vs. Court of Appeals.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 163735.  November 24, 2006

Green Asia Construction and Development Corporation, et al. Vs. Court of Appeals, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166649.  November 24, 2006

Robert B. Cabuyoc Vs. Inter-Orient Navigation Shipmanagement, Inc., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168718.  November 24, 2006

Office of the Ombudsman Vs. Farida T. Lucero and Court of Appeals .

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 171102.  November 24, 2006

ATP Technologies International, Inc. Vs. Micron Precision Phils., Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 171144.  November 24, 2006

Santos L. Nacaytuna Vs. People of the Philippines.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. RTJ-06-2002.  November 24, 2006

Rockland Construction Co., Inc. Vs. Judge Mariano M. Singzon, Jr.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 74269 / G.R. No. 92137.  November 27, 2006

Solid Homes, Inc., et al. Vs. Hon. Intermediate Appellate Court, et al. / Solid Homes, Inc., et al. Vs. Court of Appeals, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. Nos. 140371-72.  November 27, 2006

Dy Yieng Seangio, et al. Vs. Hon. Amor A. Reyes, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 149753.  November 27, 2006

Miguel Cosme, Jr. Vs. People of the Philippines.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 154685.  November 27, 2006

Metropolitan Bank and Trust Company, et al. Vs. Court of Appeals, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 158676.  November 27, 2006

BPI-Family Savings Bank, Inc. Vs. Sps. Zenaida Domingo & Abundio S. Domingo, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 158707.  November 27, 2006

Community Rural Bank of San Isidro (N.E.), Inc. Vs. Ysagani V. Paez.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166837.  November 27, 2006

Ligaya S. Orbeta Vs. Ruben P. Orbeta.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168694.  November 27, 2006

People of the Philippines Vs. Saidamin Macabalang y Malamama.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-05-1979.  November 27, 2006

Judge Leonardo P. Carreon Vs. Eric Anthony S. Ortega.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-06-2109.  November 27, 2006

Ligaya V. Reyes Vs. Mario Pablico.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-06-2268.  November 27, 2006

Bienvenido L. Punzalan Vs. Rumel M. Macalisang.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 143219.  November 28, 2006

Asian Terminals, Inc. Vs. Renato P. Villanueva, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 148090.  November 28, 2006

Stronghold Insurance Company, Inc. Vs. Hon. Nemesio S. Felix, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 150402.  November 28, 2006

Eparwa Security and Janitorial Services, Inc. Vs. Liceo De Cagayan University.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 126890.  November 28, 2006

United Planters Sugar Milling Company, Inc. (UPSUMCO) Vs. Court of Appeals, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 140833.  November 29, 2006

Lacepi T. Magnanao Vs. People of the Philippines.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 141480.  November 29, 2006

Carlos B. De Guzman Vs. Toyota Cubao, Inc..

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 143382.  November 29, 2006

Security Bank and Trust Company Vs. Mar Tierra Corporation, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 146707.  November 29, 2006

Ernesto Dumlao, Jr., et al. Vs. Rodolfo Ponferrada, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 148971.  November 29, 2006

Alberto Garong Vs. People of the Philippines.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 156294.  November 29, 2006

Melva Theresa Alviar Gonzales Vs. Rizal Commercial Banking Corporation.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 160347.  November 29, 2006

Arcadio and Maria Luisa Carandang Vs. Heirs of Quirino A. De Guzman, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 162037.  November 29, 2006

Heirs of Enrique Diaz Vs. Elinor A. Virata.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 162243 / G.R. No. 164516 / G.R. No. 171875.  November 29, 2006

Heherson Alvarez Vs. Picop Resources, Inc. / Picop Resources, Inc. Vs. Heherson Alvarez / Angelo T. Reyes Vs. Paper Industries Corp. of the Philippines (PICOP).

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 164300.  November 29, 2006

Spouses Benjamin And Agrifina Sim Vs. M.B. Finance Corporation.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 165038.  November 29, 2006

Heirs of Emilio R. Domingo and Felicidad Cornejo, et al. Vs. Heirs of Clarita D. Martin, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166496.  November 29, 2006

Josefa Bautista Ferrer Vs. Sps. Manuel M. Ferrer & Virginia Ferrer, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167723.  November 29, 2006

Club Filipino, Inc. Vs. Romeo Araullo.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169698.  November 29, 2006

Lupo Atienza Vs. Yolanda De Castro.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170840.  November 29, 2006

People of the Philippines Vs. Gregorio Carpio.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 171447.  November 29, 2006

People of the Philippines Vs. Federico Arnaiz y Armonio.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-06-2257.  November 29, 2006

Sps. Arthur And Leonora Stilgrove Vs. Eriberto R. Sabas, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. Nos. 148500-01.  November 29, 2006

Times Transportation Co. Inc. Vs. NLRC and Times Employees Union.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. Nos. 157294-95.  November 30, 2006

Joseph Victor G. Ejercito Vs. Sandiganbayan, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

Concurring Opinion

J. Callejo, Sr.

Dissenting Opinion

J. Sandoval-Gutierrez

A.C. No. 7214.  November 30, 2006

Aileen A. Ferancullo Vs. Atty. Sancho M. Ferancullo, Jr.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 129820.  November 30, 2006

Pnoc-Energy Development Corporation (PNOC-EDC) Vs. Emiliano G. Veneracion, Jr.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 135817.  November 30, 2006

Reynaldo Rodriguez and Nancy A. Rodriguez Vs. Concordia Ong Lim.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 150253.  November 30, 2006

Davao Light and Power Corporation, Inc. Vs. Antonio G. Diaz, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 152258.  November 30, 2006

Rogelio P. Antalan Vs. Hon. Aniano Desierto.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 154565.  November 30, 2006

Remedios Ramos Vs. Tessie Pabas.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 161115.  November 30, 2006

DOLE Philippines, Inc. Vs. Medel Esteva, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 164321.  November 30, 2006

Skechers, U.S.A., Inc. Vs. Inter Pacific Industrial Trading Corp., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167680.  November 30, 2006

Samuel Parilla, et al. Vs. Dr. Prospero Pilar.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168035.  November 30, 2006

Melanie M. Mesina, et al. Vs. Gloria C. Garcia.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169193.  November 30, 2006

Spouses Iluminada Capitle and Cirilo Capitle Vs. Fortunata Elbambuena and Rosalinda C. Olar.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169578.  November 30, 2006

Teresita Dio Vs. St. Ferdinand Memorial Park, Inc., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170720.  November 30, 2006

Atty. Ernesto P. Tabao, et al. Vs. Hon. Judge Eustaquio Gacott, Jr., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. Nos. 171322-24.  November 30, 2006

Marianito S. Victoriano Vs. People of the Philippines.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. MTJ-06-1660.  November 30, 2006

Spouses Trefil And Lina A. Umale Vs. Judge Nicolas V. Fadul, Jr..

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-03-1731.  November 30, 2006

PNB Management and Development Corporation Vs. Carmelo Cachero.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-06-2204.  November 30, 2006

Nydia S. Servino Vs. Ma. Mawilynn Concepcion B. Adolfo.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-06-2266.  November 30, 2006

Encarnacion Flores Vs. Romeo S. Gatcheco, Jr.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. RTJ-05-1901.  November 30, 2006

Fortune Life Insurance, Company, Inc. Vs. Judge Jimmy H. F. Luczon, Jr.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166833.  November 30, 2006

Felixberto Cubero, et al. Vs. Laguna West Multi-Purpose Cooperative, Inc., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 163712.  November 30, 2006

Metropolitan Bank and Trust Company, et al. Vs. Jose B. Tan, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 159734.  November 30, 2006

Rosario V. Astudillo Vs. People of the Philippines.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 149633.  November 30, 2006

Executive Director Gabriel S. Casal, et al. Vs. Commission on Audit.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING