October 2008

A.M. No. MTJ-03-1499.  October 6, 2008

Celfred P. Flores Vs. Judge Rodolfo B. Garcia / Judge Rodolfo B. Garcia Vs. Celfred P. Flores, Utility Worker, MCTC, Calatrava, Negros Occidental

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 135808.  October 6, 2008

Securities and Exchange Commission Vs. Interport Resources Corporation, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

Dissenting Opinion

J. Carpio

Concurring Opinion

J. Tinga

G.R. No. 156962.  October 6, 2008

Victorias Milling Co., Inc. Vs. Luis J. Padilla, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 158997.  October 6, 2008

Fort Bonifacio Development Corporation Vs. Yllas Lending Corporation, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 160338.  October 6, 2008

Ventis Maritime Corporation, et al. Vs. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 161219.  October 6, 2008

Marinduque Mining and Industrial Corp, et al. Vs. Court of Appeals & National Power Corporation

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166408.  October 6, 2008

Quezon City & the City Treasurer Vs. ABS-CBN Broadcasting Corporation

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168299.  October 6, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Luis A Ycardo

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168394.  October 6, 2008

Agrarian Reform Beneficiaries Asso. etc. Vs. Loreto G. Nicolas & Olimpio R. Cruz

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170585.  October 6, 2008

David C. Lao & Jose C. Lao Vs. Dionisio C. Lao

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 172053.  October 6, 2008

Union Bank of the Philippines Vs. Pacific Equipment Corporation, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 172370.  October 6, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Florenda Castro and Christopher Talita

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 172933.  October 6, 2008

Jesus E. Vergara Vs. Hammonia Maritime Services Inc & Atlantic Maritime Ltd.

G.R. No. 173454.  October 6, 2008

PNB Vs. Mega Prime Realty and Holdings Corporation/Mega Prime Realty and Holdings Corporation Vs. PNB

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 176637.  October 6, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Reynaldo Dela Torre

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 176724.  October 6, 2008

Mayor Kennedy B. Basmala Vs. Commission on Elections, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 177736.  October 6, 2008

Melanie-P. Montuerto Vs. Hon. Mayor Rolando E. Ty, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 178443.  October 6, 2008

Spouses Lorenzo H.Labayen, et al. Vs. Leonardo. Serafica

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 182084.  October 6, 2008

Librado M. Cabrera Vs. The Commission on Elections, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 182232.  October 6, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Nenita B. Hu

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 182421.  October 6, 2008

UCPB General Insurance Corporation Vs. Owner of M/V “Sarinderjit” Blue Rive Navigation

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. L-26112/L-30240.  October 6, 2008

Republic of the Philippines, et al. Vs. Hon Jaime Delos Angeles etc., et al.

G.R. No. 180906.  October 7, 2008

The Secretary of National Defense, et al. Vs. Manalo

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167707/G.R. No. 173775.  October 8, 2008

DENR Vs. Mayor Yap / Dr. Sacay Vs. DENR

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-08-2552.  October 8, 2008

Roberto E. Pascual Vs. Marilyn M. Martin etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.C. No. 4495.  October 8, 2008

Antonio De Zuzuarregui, Jr. Vs. Atty. Apolonia A. E. Soguilon

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-06-2249.  October 8, 2008

Judge Placido E. Marquez, et al. Vs. Luclla E. P Acariem etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 148133.  October 8, 2008

Heritage Park Management Corp. Vs. Construction Industry-Arbitration Commission, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 157680.  October 8, 2008

Equipment Technical Services etc. Vs. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 165550.  October 8, 2008

Standard Chartered Bank Vs. Standard Chartered Bank-Employees Union

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167215.  October 8, 2008

Republic of the Philippines Vs. Heirs of Evaristo Tiotioen

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168448.  October 8, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Fajardo Napudo

G.R. No. 175725.  October 8, 2008

National Power Corporation Vs. Angel Suarez, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 176706.  October 8, 2008

Manigo K. Ramos Vs. Spouses Purita G. Alvendia & Oscar Alvendia, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 181043.  October 8, 2008

The People of the Philippines Vs. Millano Muit, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 181545.  October 8, 2008

The People of the Philippines Vs. Mark Dela Cruz

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-02-1666.  October 10, 2008

Judge Tranquilino V. Ramos Vs. Rodrigo C. Bicad etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-06-2165.  October 10, 2008

Dolores Molina & Apronlano Timbol Vs. Atty. Gitanjali Bondoc, etc.

G.R. No. 157542.  October 10, 2008

Rebecca Abarbo, Eleonora R. De Jesus, Manolo A. Kagahastian & Antonio B. Magtibay Vs. Commission on Audit

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166756.  October 10, 2008

Republic of the Philippines Vs. Katrina Isabel Samson Yulo

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167627.  October 10, 2008

Agusan Del Norte Elctric Cooperative, Inc & Horacio T. Santos Vs. Joel Cagampang & Glenn Garzon

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167711.  October 10, 2008

The Office of the Ombudsman Vs. Ramon C. Galicia

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168166.  October 10, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Salvadro C. Daco

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168339.  October 10, 2008

Ma. Gregorietta Leila C. Sy Vs. ALC Industries, Inc & Dexter P. Ceriales

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168782.  October 10, 2008

Spouses Jovenal Toring & Cecilia Escalona-To Ring Vs. Spouses Rosalie Ganzon-Olan & Gilbert Olan & Rowena Olan

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 177563.  October 10, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Diosdado Balobalo

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 177775.  October 10, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Isaias Dizon

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. Nos. 183591, 183572, 183893 & 183591.  October 14, 2008

The Province of Cotobato Vs. The Gov't of the Republic of the Philippines, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

Separate Concurring Opinion

C.J. Puno, J. Ynares-Santiago, J. Carpio

Separate Concurring and Dissenting Opinion

J. Leonardo-De Castro, J. Brion

Separate Opinion

J. Azcuna, J. Tinga, J. Chico-Nazario, J. Reyes

Dissenting Opinion

J. Velasco, Jr., J. Nachura

A.M. No. 08-8-11-CA.  October 15, 2008

Letter of Presiding Justice Conrado M. Vasquez, Jr., Re: CA-G.R. SP No. 103692

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.C. No. 7091.  October 15, 2008

Jofel Legaspi Vs. Attys. Ramon Landrito and Magno Toribio

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-07-2402.  October 15, 2008

Atty. Redentor S. Viaje Vs. Rolando A. Dizon etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. RTJ-07-2034.  October 15, 2008

Atty. Nenita Ceniza-Layese Vs. Judge Enrique C. Asis etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 133347.  October 15, 2008

Abs-Cbn Broadcasting Corporation, et al. Vs. Office of the Ombudsman, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 141854.  October 15, 2008

Orlando Apostol Vs. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 147423.  October 15, 2008

Tirso Z. Oporto Vs. Members of the Board of Inquiry etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 150746.  October 15, 2008

Simeon Nicolas Chan, et al. Vs. Yolanda Chan, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 151309.  October 15, 2008

Bisig Manggagawa sa Tryco etc., et al. Vs. NLRC, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 155813.  October 15, 2008

Cecilia S. Baldueza etc. Vs. Hon. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 174971.  October 15, 2008

Land Bank of the Philippines Vs. AMS Farming Corporation

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 175832.  October 15, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Salvador Sanchez y Espiritu

G.R. No. 177135.  October 15, 2008

Arturo O. Radaza, et al. Vs. The Hon. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 178405.  October 15, 2008

Reynaldo Deus Y Santos Vs. People of the Philippines

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 172468.  October 15, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Julie Villacorta Gil

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.C. No. 1481.  October 17, 2008

Rebecca B. Arnobit Vs. Atty. Ponciano P. Arnobit

A.C. No. 6972.  October 17, 2008

Jerry T. Wong Vs. Atty. Salvador N. Moyali

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-08-2451.  October 17, 2008

Roel A Fernandez Vs. Renato Rubillos

G.R. No. 150180.  October 17, 2008

Flavio S. Suarez, Jr. et al. Vs. National Steel Corporation

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 154301.  October 17, 2008

Carlos Manangan Vs. People of the Philippines

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 164964.  October 17, 2008

National Power Corporation Vs. Maria Bagui, Vedasto Bagui, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 165389.  October 17, 2008

NFD International Manning Agents etc. Vs. NLRC, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 165622.  October 17, 2008

Mercury Drug Corporation, et al. Vs. Raul De Leon

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166502.  October 17, 2008

Francisco De Guzman Vs. People of the Philippines

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 171089.  October 17, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Rogelio Pascual

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 171452.  October 17, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Ricardo Santos

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 174224.  October 17, 2008

Marcial Aparece Vs. J. Marketing Corporation etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 176943.  October 17, 2008

Danilo Aluad, et al. Vs. Zenaido Aluad

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 177237.  October 17, 2008

William Ching Vs. People of the Philippines

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 177348.  October 17, 2008

Spouses Ramon Patron and Luzviminda Patron Vs. Union Bank of the Phil., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 177982.  October 17, 2008

Fitness By Design Inc. Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 178024.  October 17, 2008

Lawrence B. W Acnang Vs. Comelec, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 180451.  October 17, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. SPO1 Arnulfo A Aure, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 180512.  October 17, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Noel Cuasay

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 182347.  October 17, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Emilio Rivera Y Cablang

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. 06-12-720-RTC.  October 17, 2008

Re: disapproval of the permanent promotional appointment of Mr. Godofredo C. De Leon etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. 08-1982-MTJ.  October 17, 2008

Daniel P. Almaden, Jr. Vs. Hon. Victorio L. Galapon, Jr.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 121833/G.R. No. 130752.  October 17, 2008

Aboitiz Shipping Corporation Vs. CA, et al. & G.R. No. 137801 (Aboitiz Shipping Corporation Vs. Equitable Insurance Corporation)

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 143786.  October 17, 2008

Spouses Lourdes V. Rutaquio, et al. Vs. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 146141.  October 17, 2008

Ernesto P. Canada etc. Vs. All Commodities Marketing Corporation

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 157592.  October 17, 2008

Presidential Commission on Good Government Vs. Sandiganbayan, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 164052.  October 17, 2008

Anonas Construction and Industrial Supply Corp. et al. Vs. NLRC, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 164326.  October 17, 2008

Seaoil Petroleum Corporation Vs. Autocorp Group, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167500.  October 17, 2008

K-Phil., Inc. et al. Vs. Metropolitan Bank & Trust Co., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168081.  October 17, 2008

Armando G. Yrasuegui Vs. Philippine Airlines, Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169576.  October 17, 2008

Leonides Mercado etc. Vs. Court of Appeals & San Miguel Corporation

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 171790.  October 17, 2008

Brendo D. Merin Vs. NLRC etc., et al.

G.R. No. 174154 .  October 17, 2008

Jesus Cuenco Vs. Talisay Tourist Sports Complex, Inc. & Matias B. Aznar III

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 184182.  October 17, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Alfredo M. Papa

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170625.  October 17, 2008

Bank of the Philippine Islands Vs. CA & TF KO Development Corporation

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 171036.  October 17, 2008

Adela G. Raymundo, et al. Vs. Ernesto Lunaria, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 172426.  October 17, 2008

Air Transportation Office Vs. Hon. CA & Bernie G. Miaque

G.R. No. 172800.  October 17, 2008

Marciano L. Masangcay Vs. Trans-Global Maritime Agency, Inc. et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 175176.  October 17, 2008

National Power Corp. Vs. Santa Loro Vda. De Capin, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 176240.  October 17, 2008

Rolando Sasan, Sr. et al. Vs. NLRC, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 177580.  October 17, 2008

Ma. Ruby A. Dumalaog, et al. Vs. Victorio N. Medrano

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 177598.  October 17, 2008

Robert San Pedro Vs. Willy Ong & Norma Caballes

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 178449.  October 17, 2008

Metropolitan Bank and Trust Company Vs. Sps. Elisa Tan & Antonio Tan, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-05-1998.  October 24, 2008

Mayor Nicasio M. Ramos Vs. Cyril T. Mayor, Clerk III, MeTC, Br 13, Manila

A.M. No. P-06-2273.  October 24, 2008

Judge Rebecca R. Mariano Vs. Marissa R. Mondala, Court Legal Researcher II, RTC Br 136, Makati City

A.M. No. RTJ-07-2074.  October 24, 2008

OCA Vs. Ret. Judge Ireneo Lee Gako, Jr., Br Coc Manuel G. Nollora, Legal Researcher Nilda D. Suyko, Coc VII Atty. Jeoffrey S. Joaquino & Monica V. Dionaldo

G.R. No. 171008.  October 24, 2008

Carmelit A Fudot Vs. Cattley A Land, Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. MTJ-08-1721.  October 24, 2008

Michael Gamaliel Plata Vs. Judge Lizabeth G. Torres

G.R. No. 156850.  October 24, 2008

National Housing Authority Vs. Perico V. Jao etc., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 160541.  October 24, 2008

Ronelo Polo Vs. People of the Philippines

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 175587.  October 24, 2008

Philippine Commercial International Bank Vs. Joseph Anthony M. Alejandro

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 183696.  October 24, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Nelson Arraz

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.C. No. 7505.  October 24, 2008

Walter Wilkie Vs. Atty. Sinarnar E. Limos

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 153624.  October 24, 2008

Judge Morae-ion G. Angeles Vs. P/Insp. Jom A. Mamauag, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 177825.  October 24, 2008

People of the Phil. Vs. Rene Rosas

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. RTJ-07-2050.  October 29, 2008

Spouses Arleen and Lorna Oliveros Vs. Hon. Dionisio C. Sison etc.

G.R. No. 157707.  October 29, 2008

Marcial Fajardo Vs. Hon. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 160240.  October 29, 2008

Woodridge School (Now Known as Woodridge College Inc) Vs. Joanne C. Pe Benito, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 164632.  October 29, 2008

Urethane Trading Specialist Inc Vs. Edwin Ong & Leticia Ong

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 172901.  October 29, 2008

American Express International Inc. Vs. Hon. Judge Marlene Gonzales Sison etc & Maria Teresa Fernando

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 174536.  October 29, 2008

Roberto Y. Ponciano, Jr. Vs. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 175162.  October 29, 2008

Atty. Ernesto A. Tabujara III, et al. Vs. People of the Phil. and Daisy Afable

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 175692.  October 29, 2008

Angel Ubales Y Velez Vs. People of the Philippines

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 177222.  October 29, 2008

The People of the Philippines Vs. Ranilo Dela Cruz Y Lizing

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 182192.  October 29, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Agripino Guevarra Y Mulingtapang @ “Boy Dunggol”

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 154379.  October 31, 2008

PCI Travel Corporation Vs. NLRC & Nube-Amexpea/PCI Travel Employees Union

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 155758.  October 31, 2008

Heirs of Jose Esplana etc. Vs. The CA & Heirs of Pedro De Lima Represented by Jaime De Lima

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 177564.  October 31, 2008

Arturo Revita "Alias" Arthur Vs. People of the Philippines

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 163515.  October 31, 2008

Isidro T.Pajarillaga Vs. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 177647.  October 31, 2008

U-BIX Corporation & Edilberto B. Bravo Vs. Valerie Anne H. Hollero

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 178271.  October 31, 2008

Banco De Oro-Epci, Inc. Vs. Hon. Zenaida R. Daguna etc. & Phil. Devt. & International Corp.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 156882.  October 31, 2008

Banco De Oro-Epci, Inc. Vs. Hon. Zenaida R. Daguna etc. & Phil. Devt. & International Corp.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING