September 2008

G.R. No. 149189.  September 3, 2008

Leticia T. Fidelia Vs. Sps. Raul and Eleonor Mulato

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 151854.  September 3, 2008

Philux, Inc. & Max Keinle Vs. NLRC and Patricia Perjes

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 157106.  September 3, 2008

Romulo Tindoy Vs. People of the Philippines

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166996.  September 3, 2008

Philippine Airlines, Inc. et al. Vs. Bernardin J. Zamora

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167671.  September 3, 2008

Ricardo S. Santos, Jr. Vs. People of the Philippines

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168787.  September 3, 2008

Department of the Agrarian Reform etc. Vs. Polo Coconut Plantation Co. Inc. et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169549.  September 3, 2008

John Hancock Life Insurance Corp. and/or Michael Plaxton Vs. Joanna Cantre Davis

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 176504.  September 3, 2008

Ferdinand A. Cruz Vs. People of the Philippines

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 177785.  September 3, 2008

Randy Almeda, et al. Vs. Asahi Philippines Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 181546.  September 3, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Ricardo Alunday

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168742.  September 3, 2008

Republic of the Philippines Vs. Norma Royales

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 180643.  September 5, 2008

Romulo L. Neri Vs. Senate Committee on Accountability etc. et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 155703.  September 8, 2008

The Republic of the of the Philippines Vs. Dominador Santua.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 173114.  September 8, 2008

Jayson Dandan Vs. Arfel Realty & Mgt. Corp., Rafael Felix & Sps. Emerita & Carlito Sauro.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 173891.  September 8, 2008

Heirs of the late Sps. Luciano P. Lim & Salud Nakpil Bautista etc. Vs. The Presiding Judge of the RTC of Q.C. etc., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. 08-8-11-CA.  September 9, 2008

Re: Letter of Presiding Justice Conrado M. Vasquez, Jr. on CA-G.R. No. 103692 [Antonio Rosete, et al. Vs. Securities and Exchange Commission, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.C. No. 6505.  September 11, 2008

Jessica C. Uy Vs. Atty. Emmanuel P. Sano

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 139047/G.R. No. 139365.  September 11, 2008

Sps. Emma H. Ver Reyes etc. Dominador Salvador, Sr. et al./Maria Q. Cristobal, et al. Vs. Dominador Salvador, Sr. et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 150635.  September 11, 2008

Dr. Rosalina G. Hilario Vs. Modesto Prudential, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 151110.  September 11, 2008

Spl. Pol. Lt. Ramon C. Torredes Vs. Carlos Villamor

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 154464.  September 11, 2008

Ferdinand A. Cruz etc. Vs. Judge Prescilla Mijares, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166096.  September 11, 2008

Philippine National Bank Vs. Ramon Brigido L. Velasco

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 174899.  September 11, 2008

Ramon L. Uy Vs. People of the Philippines

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 175573.  September 11, 2008

Office of the Ombudsman Vs. Joel S. Samaniego

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 176159.  September 11, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Lee Rodrigo

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 180500.  September 11, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Medardo Crespo Y Lopez

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.C. No. 7781.  September 12, 2008

Dolores L. Dela Cruz, et al. Vs. Atty. Jose R. Dimaanno, Jr.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.C. No. 7820.  September 12, 2008

Atty. Ricardo M. Salomon, Jr. Vs. Atty. Joselito C. Frial

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 160725.  September 12, 2008

National Power corporation Vs. Purefoods Corporation, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 161057.  September 12, 2008

Betty Gabioza & Isabelita Tan Vs. CA, Luke Roxas & Evelyn Nolasco

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

Dissenting Opinion

J. Velasco

G.R. No. 166676.  September 12, 2008

Republic of the Philippines Vs. Jennifer B. Cagandahan

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168637/G.R. No. 170684.  September 12, 2008

Michael J. Lagrosas Vs. Bristol-Myers Squibb (Phil.), Inc./Mead Johnson Phil., et al./Bristol-Myers Squibb (Phil.), Inc./Mead Johnson Phil., et al. Vs. CA & Michael J. Lagrosas

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169400.  September 12, 2008

Napoleon G. Rama Vs. Spouses Eduardo and Conchita Joaquin

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169657.  September 12, 2008

Lt. (ret.) Eduardo De Ocampo Vs. PO3 Euzueto R. Rey

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170266.  September 12, 2008

Engracio A. Guerzon, Jr., et al. Vs. Pasig Industries, Inc., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170738.  September 12, 2008

Rizal Commercial Banking Corporation Vs. Marcopper Mining Corporation

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170852.  September 12, 2008

Spouses Noe and Clarita Quiampo Vs. Capital Insurance & Surety Co., Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 172129.  September 12, 2008

Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. Mirant Pagbilao Corp.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 172677.  September 12, 2008

Isagani Yambot, et al. Vs. Raymundo A. Armovit, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 174098.  September 12, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Reynaldo Teczon Y. Pascual

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 174346.  September 12, 2008

Fernanda Geonzon Vda De Barrera & Johnny Oco, Jr. Vs. Heirs of Vicente Legaspi etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 177297.  September 12, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Claudio Zulueta, Sr.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 181633.  September 12, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Roger Ugos

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 152359 & G.R. No. 174103.  September 16, 2008

Development Bank of the Philippines Vs. Court of Appeals & West Negros College, Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 154716.  September 16, 2008

Far East Bank & Trust Co. et al. Vs. Trust Union Shipping Corp., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 155491.  September 16, 2008

Smart Commuications, Inc. Vs. The City of Davao Rep. Herein by its Mayor Hon. Rodrigo R. Duterte, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 159308.  September 16, 2008

Republic of the Philippines etc. Vs. Pagadian City Timber Co. Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 161032.  September 16, 2008

Erwin Tulfo Vs. People of the Philippines & Atty. Carlos T. So./Susan Cambri, Rey Salao, Jocelyn Barlizo & Philip Pichay Vs. CA, People of the Philippines & Carlos So

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 165012.  September 16, 2008

Rachel Beatriz Ruivivar Vs. Office of the Ombudsman & Dr. Connie Bernardo

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 172871.  September 16, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Clemente Casta Y carolino

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 183806-08.  September 16, 2008

Mayor Abraham N. Tolentino Vs. Commission on Elections, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 138823.  September 17, 2008

Caridad Magkalas Vs. National Housing Authority

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 150536.  September 17, 2008

Bienvenido Gomba Vs. People of the Philippines

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 156076.  September 17, 2008

Sps. Jesus Ching & Lee Poe Tin Vs. Sps. Adolfo & Arsenia Enrile

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 156208.  September 17, 2008

NPC Drivers and Mechanics Asso. et al. Vs. The National Power Corp, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 156482.  September 17, 2008

Pedro Gabriel, et al. Vs. Murmura Y Jamias, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167560.  September 17, 2008

Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. Dominador Menguito

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169444.  September 17, 2008

Pablito T. Villari& P.R. Builders Developers & Managers Inc. Vs. Coronado P. Munasque

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170247.  September 17, 2008

Heirs of Benjamin Mendoza etc. Vs. The Hon. CA & J.A Development Corp.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 171827.  September 17, 2008

Teresita Monzon Vs. Sps. James & Maria Rosa Nieves Relova & Sps. Bienvenido & Eufracia Perez

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 172238.  September 17, 2008

Ma. Liza Franco-Cruz Vs. The CA, Victory Liner, Inc. et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 172248.  September 17, 2008

Development Bank of the Phil. Vs. Ella Gagarani, Isagani, Adrian, Nathaniel, Nieva, Jonathan, Dionesio, Florence & Jeremias All Surnamed Asok

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 173242.  September 17, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Esperidion Balais

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 173283.  September 17, 2008

Scenarios, Inc &/Or Rhotziv Bago Vs. Jelly Vinluan

G.R. No. 173808.  September 17, 2008

Fernanda Arbias Vs. The Hon. CA & The Republic of the Philippines

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 174569.  September 17, 2008

China Banking Corp, et al. Vs. Benjamin Co, Engr. Dale Olea, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 174711.  September 17, 2008

Sally Sueno Vs. Land Bank of the Philippines

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 175550.  September 17, 2008

Dasmarinas Water District Vs. Monterey Food Corporation

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 177667.  September 17, 2008

Cleodia U. Francisco, et al. Vs. Sps Jorge C. Gonzales & Purificacon W. Gonzales.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 179718.  September 17, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Lourdes V. Legaspi

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. 2007-25-SC.  September 18, 2008

Ronnie C. dela Cruz Vs. Redentor A. Zapico, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-03-1715.  September 19, 2008

Felisa L. Gonzales Vs. Clerk of Court, Joseph N. Escalona & Sheriff Iv Edgar V. Superada

G.R. No. 153077.  September 19, 2008

Dolores Salinas etc. Vs. Sps. Bienvenido S. Faustino & Iluminada G.Faustino

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 157125.  September 19, 2008

Iluminada “Lumen” Policarpio Vs. Active Bank

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 165896.  September 19, 2008

Rustico Abay, Jr. & Reynaldo Darilag Vs. People of the Philippines

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167709.  September 19, 2008

Republic of the Philippines Vs. Heirs of Pascual Ocariza represented by by co-heir Remeios Bacalso

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167962.  September 19, 2008

Antam Pawnshop Corp. Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168050.  September 19, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Bernardino Gaefud, Jr.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170415.  September 19, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Jesus Castro Y Celedonio

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-03-1748.  September 22, 2008

Office of the Court Administrator Vs. Llbrada C. Puno, Cash Clerk III, Office of the Clerk of Court, Cabanatuan City

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-07-2335.  September 22, 2008

Civil Service Commission Vs. Caridad S. Dasco, Stenographer II, MeTC Br 64 Makati City

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 123238.  September 22, 2008

Philippine Airlines, Inc. Vs. Court of Appeals, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 158642.  September 22, 2008

Estate of Don Felimon Y. Sotto represented by its administrator, Sixto Sotto Pahang, Jr. Vs. Matilde S. Palicte etc., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 159220.  September 22, 2008

Ma. Darlene Dimayuga-Laurena Vs. Court of Appeals & Jesse Lauro Laurena

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167383.  September 22, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Amadeo Tinsay

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 174312.  September 22, 2008

Capt. Ernesto S. Caballero Vs. Philippine Coast Guard Efficiency and Separation Board (PCG-ESB), et al.

Separate Concurring Opinion

J. Carpio

A.C. No. 6737.  September 23, 2008

Flocerfida S. Lanuzo Vs. Atiy. Jesus B. Bongon

G.R. No. 162525.  September 23, 2008

Asean Pacific Planners, et al. Vs. City of Urdaneta, Ceferino J. Capalad, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 165153.  September 23, 2008

Carlos E. De Castro Vs. Liberty Broadcasting Network, Inc. & Edgardo Quiogue

G.R. No. 165275.  September 23, 2008

Goretti Ong Vs. People of the Philippines

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167691.  September 23, 2008

Camarines Sur IV Electric Cooperative, Inc. Vs. Expedita L. Aquino

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170943.  September 23, 2008

Pedro Santos, Jr. Vs. PNOC Exploration. Corporation

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 173318.  September 23, 2008

U-Bix Corporation Vs. Milliken & Company, Sylvan Chemical Company, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 173483.  September 23, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Merlie Dumangay Y Sale

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 175995.  September 23, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Edwin Fuentes Y Carson

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-07-2380.  September 25, 2008

Absence without leave of Ms. Lydia Ramil etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. RTJ-08-2127.  September 25, 2008

Cita Borromeo-Garcia Vs. Judge Ernesto P. Pagayatan etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 156364.  September 25, 2008

Jacobus Bernhard Hulst Vs. PR Builders, Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 163838.  September 25, 2008

Wallem Maritime Services, Inc. et al. Vs. NLRC, et al.

G.R. No. 164850.  September 25, 2008

Reynaldo Q. Agullano Vs. Christian Publishing, et al.

G.R. No. 168309.  September 25, 2008

Office of the Ombudsman Vs. Marian D. Torres, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 173375.  September 25, 2008

Leoncio D. Mangahas, et al. Vs. The Hon. Court of Appeals, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 181632.  September 25, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Jesse Ballesta

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-06-2233.  September 26, 2008

Judge Henry B. Basila Vs. Yolanda L. Ricafort

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 163749.  September 26, 2008

Spouses Julian santiago, Sr. et al. Vs. Bank of the Philippines Islands etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 164314.  September 26, 2008

Securities and Exchange Commission Vs. Picop Resources Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168074.  September 26, 2008

Empire East Land Holdings Inc. Vs. Capitol Industrial Construction Groups, Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168561.  September 26, 2008

Tacloban II Neighborhood Association Inc. Vs. Office of the President, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170325.  September 26, 2008

Philippines National Bank Vs. Erlando T. Rodriguez, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 174649.  September 26, 2008

Leopoldo Jeremias, et al. Vs. The Estate of the Late Irene P. Mariano etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 180557.  September 26, 2008

Heirs of Roque F. Tabuena, et al. Vs. Land Bank of the Philippines

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 181747.  September 26, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Narciso Agulay y Lopez

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

Dissenting Opinion

J. Brion

G.R. No. 182718.  September 26, 2008

Julio B. Purcon, Jr. Vs. MRM Philippines, Inc., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169558.  September 29, 2008

Philippine Crop Insurance Corp. Vs. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 172306.  September 29, 2008

Michael V. Santos Vs. Shing Hung Plastics Co., Inc., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 172744.  September 29, 2008

Marvin Angeles Vs. People of the Philippines

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 175175.  September 29, 2008

Land Bank of the Philippines Vs. Heirs of Eleuterio Cruz

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 177571.  September 29, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Dean Martin Y Savida @ Denden, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 177874.  September 29, 2008

Jaime D. Ang Vs. Bruno Soledad

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 178545.  September 29, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Leo Barriga, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 179939.  September 29, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Geraldine Magat Y Paderon

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 180394.  September 29, 2008

Marjorie B. Cadimas, Represented by her Atty-In-Fact, Venancio Z. Rosales Vs. Marites Carrion, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.C. No. 7902.  September 30, 2008

Torben V. Overgaard Vs. Atty. Godwin R. Valdez

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. MTJ -06-1631.  September 30, 2008

Fenina R. Santos Vs. Judge Erasto D. Tanciongco

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-06-2137.  September 30, 2008

Re: Unauthorized absences from the post of pearl Marie N. Icamina etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 142977.  September 30, 2008

Leonor Camcam, et al. Vs. Hon. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 148433.  September 30, 2008

Zamboanga Barter Traders Kilusang Bayan, Inc. etc. Vs. Hon. Julius Rhett J. Plagata, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 159808.  September 30, 2008

Leopard Integrated Services, Inc. and/or Jose Poe Vs. Virgilio Macalinao

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 165993.  September 30, 2008

Merida Water District, et al. Vs. Francisco Bacarro, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168578-79.  September 30, 2008

Nieto A. Racho Vs. Hon. Primo C. Miro, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168852.  September 30, 2008

Sharica Marl L. Go-Tan Vs. Spouses Perfecto C. Tan & Juanita L. Tan

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170569.  September 30, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Norberto Mateo Y Dizon

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 173106.  September 30, 2008

Cosme Nacario Vs. People of the Philippines

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 178505.  September 30, 2008

Cherry J. Price, et al. Vs. National Labor Relations Commission, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 179402.  September 30, 2008

National Union of Workers In Hotels, et al. Vs. Acesite Philippine Hotel Corp.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 181631.  September 30, 2008

The People of the Philippines Vs. Jose Balinas, Jr.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 182548.  September 30, 2008

People of the Philippines Vs. Cesario Osianas, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING